G20: Bonus for the poor?
Written by Trade Out of Poverty founders Tuesday, 22 September 2009 15:07
This will hurt people even in the most prosperous countries. But it will also divert attention from some simple steps G20 leaders could take to help citizens of the poorest countries on earth. For them, the failure to join in trade can be a matter of life and death.
Ironically, promoting global trade and investment, as well as rejecting protectionism, won’t cost much. No expensive TARP or other government bailout packages are necessary. No nitty-gritty Doha Round either. Trade is the single best route out of poverty and there are five fairly simple steps the G20 and others can take to allow the poorest countries to trade their way out of poverty.
First, rich countries must open their markets unconditionally to all the poorest countries (the UN-defined Low Income Countries, including Ghana). Although protectionism is a common reaction at times of economic uncertainty it will hurt rich and poor in the long run. The threat of competition to rich countries is minimal: the poorest people, with people living on less than $2.70 a day, account for one fifth of the world’s population but less than one fiftieth of world trade.
Second, trade rules must also be simplified. Complex rules of origin mean that countries that are entitled in theory to tariff-free access to developed markets are actually paying high tariffs or being excluded by the complications of bureaucratic barriers.
Third, rich countries’ export and domestic subsidies which undermine poor countries’ ability to compete should be reduced or removed. Among the worst examples are Japanese rice, US cotton and European Union cows.
Separately, poor countries need to make a number of changes too, especially reducing tariffs between themselves. The highest tariffs in the world are between the poorest countries, where governments and customs officials abuse trade regulations and damage regional trade.
The World Bank's latest Doing Business study shows that exporting a container from an Angolan port requires an average of 12 documents, costs $2,250 and will take a massive 68 days to clear, while in landlocked Botswana it takes 37 days yet in Senegal it only takes 14 days--better than the world average.
This is one of the reasons why less than one tenth of African exports go to other African countries, while nearly three quarters of European trade is within Europe.
Finally, renewed investment is essential in the roads, ports and administrative structures that would make trade possible or easier in developing countries. And it's not just external trade: in 2006 Kenya could not get its agricultural surplus in the West to the famine-stricken North, which had to wait for international humanitarian aid.
Lifting all barriers in the G20 is cheap and easy: in practice, each G20 country could act alone. But if the G20 worked together and devoted only a little of the time and energy it will give to bankers’ bonuses at this week’s Summit, the bonus for the poor would be measured not in millions of dollars but in lives: poverty kills but trade saves.
Messrs. Battle, Campbell, Hastings and Lilley and Ms. Short, members of the British Parliament, are co-chairs of the cross-party Trade Out of Poverty campaign.
| Comments |
|
!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."
Cast Your Vote
Should the Government of Ghana proceed with the STX Housing deal considering the terms and implications?
Audio on Demand
Resources
GoG, HFC, STX Joint Venture Agreement
view
Ghana's GDP Revised
view
BoG - Annual Percentage Rages (May 2010)
view
STX - Off-Taker Agreement
view
STX - Memorandum of Understanding
view
STX - Executive Approval
view
GoG STX Housing
view
Overview of GoG STX Housing Agreement
by Gabby Asare Otchere-Darko view
Right to Information Bill
view
Right ot Information Bill - Momorandum
view
Regina Vs Mabey & Johnson
view
Databank - Ghana's Economic Update (March 2010)
view
Asian Perspectives on Governance
view
International Corruption and Money Laundering Presentations
International Corruption
by John Hardy QC
Risks of Money Laundering
by KPMG
Protecting Ghana from Money Laundering
by John Hardy QC
Financial Intelligence Centre
by S T Essel
Danquah Institute's Opinion
Report on Conference
"The annual Danquah Institute Governance and Development Dialogue Series was held at the Alisa Hotel, North Ridge, Accra, Ghana, from the 8-9 February 2010. This year’s series was themed: ‘National Conference on Biometric Voter Registration and Electronic Voting’. Invitations were extended to all political parties. Participants included the General Secretary and Youth Organiser of the Convention People’s Party, the National Chairman and General Secretary of the People’s National Convention and the National Chairman and Director of Research of the New Patriotic Party. more >>>
Experience of E-Voting Overseas
"The use of electronic voting worldwide remains a relatively uncommon practice, although this is rapidly changing as countries experiment with various electronic methods or expand their existing use of electronic voting. Furthermore, electronic voting is not limited to Europe or North America, as countries such as Brazil and India have embraced electronic voting far more completely than Europe, the United States, or Canada. more >>>
Ghana: Let the Good News Roll
"The transition to a new government under the NDC sig- nificantly diluted the policy environment during much of H1:09. Despite the slow start, the NDC government has been prepared to grapple with the thorny issue of fiscal overspending and has introduced meaningful austerity measures, including removing a number of subsidies despite their popular appeal. more >>>
Viability Of Electronic Voting
"The fundamental question to be addressed before 2012 is how do we protect the integrity of the elections from the point of voter registration to the moment of winner certification?.
Linked to this is the question, what are the factors that influence public confidence in elections.more >>>
2010 Budget Highlights
"Among the many challenges faced by the new Government when they took office in January 2009 were the effects of a global recession on the country, a period of unusually high food prices, pressure on the Ghana Cedi and a significant budget deficit.
It was therefore not surprising that 2009 was dedicated to taking control of the Government machinery, appraising the available resources, obligations and commitments and stabilising the economy.more >>>
VAT To Rise
"The Danquah Institute (DI) has called on the Government of the Republic of Ghana to come clean and warn Ghanaians beforehand how much it intends to raise VAT and electricity prices in line with Government’s policy to strengthen the fiscal state of the national economy.
With the end of September less than a week away, DI is also asking for the President Mills administration to let Ghanaians know how far it has gone in fulfilling the conditionalities set out in its June agreement with the World Bank, covering a $300 million credit facility.more >>>
Information Center
For any information regarding what we represent, please feel free to contact us on the details below.
- Hot line: (+233) 21 782878
- Fax: (+233) 21 782906
- Email: info@danquahinstitute.org
- Website: www.danquahinstitute.org

"Our mission is to make a courageous, imaginative and constructive contribution to nation-building and development, with the purpose of enhancing the life of every individual citizen" - J.B Danquah

